Movie Review: Dreamgirls

Paramount bought the rights to produce a film version of the hit Broadway musical Dreamgirls back in the 80s, but it's taken this long for the project to actually come to fruition. Maybe they were waiting for the right director, maybe they were waiting for the right talent or time, or maybe it was just difficult to convince someone a movie about three black girls pursuing their dreams would sell to the mainstream public. But even if it is many years later, fans of the original show are no less delighted that the legendary production has finally made its way to the big screen.
The movie doesn't actually come out until Christmas day nationwide, but I was lucky enough to catch one of the $25 roadshow screenings in New York city, complete with costume pieces, a program and mini-poster, the works. Being in a room full of people who obviously really wanted to see the movie enhanced the moviegoing experience, especially for a film like this which is built to be an audience pleaser. People clapped, danced, sang along if they knew the words, and cheered on the stars of the movie, who obviously were not there to hear the lavish applause.
It's often difficult going in to view a film that's been so ridiculously hyped, because it's unlikely that the movie will ever meet your expectations, and this case was no exception to the rule. The story revolves around three young black girls in Detroit with aspirations of being a famous singing girl group a la The Supremes. Many people on the record have claimed the film is not based on The Supremes, but it's been made obvious time and time again that it clearly is. Though one of the members of the group recently appeared on Access Hollywood stating the movie does not accurately portray Diana Ross–the real person was much worse. Ouch.
Nonetheless, the film is essentially centered around Effie White, who is clearly the most talented of the three girls as made clear by one of the early numbers where newcomer Jennifer Hudson (think third season of American Idol) sings her face off while the other girls stand behind her singing Oohs and Ahhs. Singing "Oohs and Ahhs" is something Effie later claims she doesn't do once approached by sly as a snake manager Curtis Taylor (Jamie Foxx), who offers them a chance to sing back-up for a male singer. The girls eventually convince Effie to do it, as it could lead to them hitting it big, and she reluctantly obliges once Curtis butters her up a bit.
The girls eventually end up recording a minor hit, but right before it gets big, a white artist covers their song, and it rockets up the pop charts–making it impossible for the Dreamettes' version to continue climbing. Curtis and Effie develop a relationship along the way, whilst Lorelle, played by Tony winner Anika Noni Rose falls for Eddie Murphy's character James "Thunder" Early–a James Brown-like R&B singer that refuses to water down his soulful and funky music to appeal to white audiences.
The pivotal moment in the film comes half way through, when after Effie has been bumped down from the lead singer and replaced by the prettier but less talented Deena (Beyonce Knowles), she then gets completely knocked out of the group–and also realizes Curtis is sleeping with Deena. This is when Jennifer belts out the most mind-blowing musical number I've seen on the screen since Barbra Stresand's heartbreaking "My Man" in Funny Girl. "I'm Telling You I'm Not Going" is surreal.
All the musical numbers in this movie are great, but this one will have your spine tingling, your bones chilling, your hairs raised, and all the wigs flying. Aside from just the incredible vocal performance Hudson gives on the song, the emotional, powerful, and gutwrenching performance she gives on the screen is indescribable. In a theater packed full of hundreds of eager New Yorkers who all paid $25 a ticket, there were people throwing their hands up, clapping and cheering mid-song, and even jumping out of their seats to give Hudson a standing ovation at the end of the number. Throughout the entire movie, Hudson gives a surprisingly riveting performance. She nails Effie in every sense of the word–without even looking like a beginner. Her attitude oozes off the screen and right into your lap, and you love her for it. She might as well clear space on her shelf for her Oscar now.
Hudson and Murphy are clearly the standouts in this film, and should garner many awards and accollades for giving magnetic and scene-stealing performances in a film bigger than both of them. Unfortunately, the same raves cannot be given to the other actors, or the film as a whole. The good screenwriters in Hollywood must be on a strike, because along with The Pursuit of Happyness and Bobby, the biggest flaw in Dreamgirls is the script–and thus the actors are what make the movie. None of the characters are developed well enough, and the only character to have even close the appropriate amount of characterization is Lorelle, which is probably more a testament to the actress' ample abilities than to Bill Condon (Chicago) who wrote and directed the film.
Even the character who is bound to be the audience favorite, Effie White, lacks emotional depth and dimensions. We kind of understand Effie's actions based on the surrounding circumstances, but we don't get to see anything more of her than what is there at face value (the same can be said for all the characters)–and if we had, it would've made "I'm Telling You I'm Not Going" that much more poignant.
Eddie Murphy is a complete riot all throughout the film, sans the grim third act which is all but funny. This is honestly the performance of his career. Through his energetic moves, hip thrusts and turns, excellent singing and red-blooded charisma, Murphy is captivating every moment he's on screen. He and Hudson are really rich icing on a cake that's missing many of its key ingredients.
Ironically, the movie's two biggest stars, Jamie Foxx and Beyonce Knowles, are the weak links in the film. Foxx's one-note performance is reminiscent of a made-for-tv movie, and his singing is near embarassing–which is interesting because he is a singer. When Eddie Murphy is outsinging you, the professional musician, you know there's a problem. Given that this is Hudson's first film, it makes no sense that she would give a more committed, nuanced performance than Miss Knowles, who we've seen grace the screen before, and unsuccessfully.
Knowles, like many bad actors, think it's enough to just show up and say your lines. Though her character Deena is supposed to be quite dull, that doesn't excuse being stiff and lost. You look at her face while she's saying her lines and while the other actors are speaking and it's like looking into the eyes of a porcelain doll. It's really pretty, but there's nothing there. Even the one moment in the film when Deena steps up and takes charge–Beyonce cheesily takes a puff of her cigarette and spouts out something that would've been sassy, had she worked a little harder at challenging herself as an actress.
Despite being as mediocre as expected for most of the movie, there is one number newly created for the film called "Listen" in Act II that Beyonce hits out of the park. She completely caught me off guard, and nearly had me shaking with the intensity of her performance. The vocals aside, she truly felt and portrayed the emotion on the track, and for the first time in the entire film got cheers from the audience for nailing the number. If only she had been in the moment like this for the rest of the movie.
The costumes, make-up, lighting, and cinematography are all gorgeous, and some great performers make this film worth going to see the film. The surprisingly sloppy script and directing from mega-talented Condon keep it from being a one-two knockout.










The film’s best asset is it’s leading lady Kate Bosworth whose Lois Lane is a bit different from what we’re used to–she’s less bubbly, a bit more Katharine Hepburn and less Julia Roberts than you’d expect from the hapless reporter–but after getting over the initial shock of the change of character you come to appreciate her take on Lois, and she quickly becomes more interesting than the superhero on which the movie is named. There are interesting things we find out about Lois’ son and their relation to Superman throughout the movie, and the love triangle between Superman, Lois, and her husband Richard (X-Men’s James Marsden) adds layers and drama to the story.
I must say, that despite my displeasure with most of the movie, the end was quite emotional, and due to the talents of Kate Bosworth and Tristan Lake Leabu, I was moved–nearly to tears. The very end of the film is a little dissatisfying, but you could say the same about the first X-Men film, which was merely starting the story up–whereas X2 is where the real story began. As it looks now, Bryan Singer made a horrible choice abandoning X-Men: The Last Stand for this film–not only did X-Men do better at the box office (Superman only made 84 million this past week–not even half its budget), but if Bryan had stayed with the film it probably would have been a much better movie too.
Noah Baumbach’s honest and often funny screenplay feels so completely natural and pure that throughout the film I had to remind myself I was even watching a movie. There is a special way the writing, directing, and impeccable acting came together in this movie that just made this film something special. Films like this only come around once in a blue moon, and thank God Baumbach picked up just the right performers to bring this semi-autobiographical story to life.
Walt (Jesse Eisenberg), the older of the two sons, seems to be more angry than sad, and immediately blames his mother for the end of the relationship–no doubt with a little help from Daddy. Walt idolizes his father in every way–he repeats to his friends his father’s opinions on books without reading them himself, he asks and takes his father’s advice about women and disregards the feelings he has of his own, and even listens to Bernard’s negative comments about Joan without even caring what her side of the story is.
Baumbach really has created a tour de force film that I’d call one of the best I’ve seen in a decade. For 81 minutes my eyes were glued to the screen. I couldn’t have looked away for a second even if I wanted to.
At first Akeelah is apprehensive, not only because she’s afraid of failing, but also because she doesn’t want her less capable peers to think of her as “braniac”, something other kids at school already label her and ridicule her for. She gets A’s on her tests without even studying and her teachers see a lot of potential in her (she even skipped a grade), but she skips school a lot and sometimes doesn’t even do her homework. In her impoverished “ghetto” neighborhood, being smart doesn’t exactly make you a rock star. Two girls who are obviously on Akeelah’s case a lot, even start bullying her to get her to do their English homework.
Akeelah has many people that help her along the way, including the people in her downtrodden community–from her brothers and sisters (even her other troubled brother who has been causing their mother grief by hanging out with gangbangers) to her friends (including a Spanish boy she meets at the regional bee played by J.R. Villarreal that provides a comic but tender aspect to the film) to random people in the community, eventually even her mother, and of course, Dr. Larabee.
All of the performances in this movie are pitch perfect. Angela Bassett, brilliant as always, turns what could’ve been a flat character into someone three-dimensional and fully fleshed out–bringing life to Akeelah’s still grieving single mother. Laurence Fishburne proves once again why he is one of the best black actors that has ever lived, breathing heart and soul into Dr. Larabee, a character similar to that of the one he played in “Searching For Bobby Fischer“, but different and disctinct enough to be perfect for this film. The performances that will get the closest to your heart though, are that of the child actors Keke Palmer and J.R. Villarreal. Palmer infuses truth and genuineness into what other child actors might have left bland and predictable, and her co-star Villarreal has one of the most lighthearted, endearing performances I’ve ever seen from such a young actor.
But when I thought about it, I realized that there actually were decent movies out. I loved Capote,
Yes, all of the characters may not have been completely fleshed out and three-dimensional, yes, much of the film may have been manipulative and slightly contrived, and yes, the portrayals of the events and how they pan out in the film are not all necessarily realistic — but my question is “Who cares?” It was such a brilliantly done film from the first frame to the very last. The completely original, risky, and thought provoking
This is all to say what, exactly? Well two things: one, Crash, like Intolerance, is yet another example of people simply disliking a film because of controversial themes that people don’t want to deal with and thereby disregarding the quality of the film itself; and two, as Paul Haggis tried to explain in his Oscar acceptance speech, art isn’t necessarily a Shakespearian mirror held up to nature, but also a Brechtian hammer to reshape society. And if these so-called “cliche” characters and lines that Haggis and Moresco used as puppets to create this incredible interweaving story of love, corruption, indifference, regret, pain, prejudice, and hypocrisy are not entirely realistic, that’s okay. Art is not something you can truly define. It is not something you can wrap up and put into a box. True art is created when thinking outside of the box. And that’s what makes this screenplay and this film so unforgettable for me.




The reason Clarkson is so successful in her craft, unlike her succeeding Idol winners, is because not only does she posess great talent, but she strives for excellence in her music. She wants to be more than just a pop star with a good career. Right now, her music is only good, but over time she will evolve into a full-fledged musician, and she will surprise the likes of everyone.

The characters are all one-dimensional: Tom Cruise plays the deadbeat dad; Dakota Fanning at first seems to be playing a precocious youngster, but as soon as the aliens hit, randomly becomes a kind of “Lois Lane” of the film–constantly being picked up, grabbed, pushed out of harm’s way, and frankly at quite the expense of the annoyed audience member; Justin Chatwin plays the rebellious teenager who refuses to accept Tom Cruise as a father figure.